Fighting the good fight Nationally
Appeals Court Rules in WB’s Favor in KB Home Suit
A three-judge panel unanimously ruled Dec. 17 that a class-action lawsuit may continue against KB Home Raleigh/Durham, Inc.
The class action alleges that KB, the defendant, improperly built homes without installing barriers behind the siding to prevent water from penetrating and damaging the structures’ interiors. Although the suit was filed in December 2008, the defendant waited three and a half years to seek arbitration and decertify the class.
In ruling for the plaintiffs in Elliott et al v. KB Home Raleigh/Durham, Inc., North Carolina Court of Appeals Judge Linda McGee affirmed the trial court’s denial of a motion to compel arbitration in the construction defect class action. Referring to the time period the defendant waited before raising the defense that it had contractual rights to arbitration, McGee said the court could not sanction such “gamesmanship.”
Whitfield Bryson LLP represents the homeowners who are seeking remediation of their houses, which would include removal of the exterior siding and placement of a weather resistant barrier such as Tyvek. Approximately 500 homeowners are in the class.
“We will continue to try to vindicate the rights of these homeowners,” said Jason Rathod, WB attorney. “We plan to get a trial date set, take this to trial in the next year and prevail.”
The plaintiffs have a right to trial, as arbitration denies aggrieved individuals their day in court and prevents consumers from joining together to hold corporations accountable, he said. “We were able to preserve the ability of these homeowners to band together and vindicate their rights in a public court of law, rather than in the closed corridors of a private arbitration,” Rathod said.
Scott’s practice focuses on fighting for individuals and homeowners in complex litigation, including construction defect, mass tort, product liability, and wrongful death litigation. Scott’s success has been recognized by numerous professional associations. He was named a Super Lawyer in 2010, and every year since 2012.Read bio
John Whitfield has been significant in his management of a suit involving the death of my son in a motorcycle accident. His professionalism, compassion, support, and especially his knowledge base in this suit has been above reproach. He has communicated well and kept all parties apprised of the status of the suit. I feel he negotiated effectively to reach the best possible settlement for my son's estate. He certainly assures his clients are represented well. I am grateful for his successfully bringing this suit to a satisfactory conclusion. In short, John's expertise has been awesome.
I am very grateful to Whitfield Bryson for taking the initiative in filing suit against the manufacturers of defective CSST pipe. I am sure that this successful litigation will now help Maryland homeowners become aware of the danger of old style CSST pipe and to let them know what steps they may take to protect themselves against those dangers. Who knows how many lives and homes may be saved as a result of his efforts. Thank you for your important work in this litigation.